Back to Skills

formatting-audits

verified

Design document review format with 100-point scoring system for SOW/Spec. Use when reviewing SOW or Spec documents, scoring design quality, or when user mentions SOW review, Spec review, 設計書レビュー, 品質スコア, document scoring.

View on GitHub

Marketplace

thkt-development-workflows

thkt/claude-config

Plugin

development-skills

Development Skills

Repository

thkt/claude-config
3stars

skills/formatting-audits/SKILL.md

Last Verified

January 22, 2026

Install Skill

Select agents to install to:

Scope:
npx add-skill https://github.com/thkt/claude-config/blob/main/skills/formatting-audits/SKILL.md -a claude-code --skill formatting-audits

Installation paths:

Claude
.claude/skills/formatting-audits/
Powered by add-skill CLI

Instructions

# SOW/Spec Scoring (100-point)

## Scoring

| Category      | Score | Focus                       |
| ------------- | ----- | --------------------------- |
| Accuracy      | 0-25  | ✓/→/? markers, evidence     |
| Completeness  | 0-25  | All sections, testable AC   |
| Relevance     | 0-25  | Goals ↔ solutions, no YAGNI |
| Actionability | 0-25  | Specific steps, feasibility |

## Deductions

| Issue                    | Points |
| ------------------------ | ------ |
| No confidence marker     | -5     |
| Missing required section | -10    |
| AC without test scenario | -5     |
| Vague action item        | -5     |
| YAGNI violation          | -5     |
| Inconsistent AC-FR map   | -10    |

## Thresholds

| Score  | Judgment    | Action                |
| ------ | ----------- | --------------------- |
| 90-100 | PASS        | Proceed to next phase |
| 70-89  | CONDITIONAL | Re-review after fixes |
| 0-69   | FAIL        | Major revision needed |

Validation Details

Front Matter
Required Fields
Valid Name Format
Valid Description
Has Sections
Allowed Tools
Instruction Length:
808 chars